Monthly Archives: November 2009

Hot Springs, AR: “Pit bull” ban on agenda, Dec 1

Crossposted from BSL Updates:

The Hot Springs Board of Directors will consider an ordinance Tuesday night (December 1, 2009) that, if adopted, would ban ownership of “pit bulls” within the city limits.

Board meetings begin at 7:00 p.m. and are held at Board Chambers in the Hot Springs Municipal Building

The meeting is TOMORROW night. Please send your POLITE AND RESPECTFUL opposition to breed specific legislation to the city officials listed below. Please also send your suggestions and viable alternatives. Time is of the essense, so please take action TODAY.

Jodi Preis
Bless the Bullys
www.blessthebullys.com

City Clerk Janet Heath
jheath@cityhs.net

City Manager Lance Hudnell
lhudnell@cityhs.net 

City Attorney Brian Albright
balbright@cityhs.net

ORDINANCE NO. O-09-43

AN ORDINANCE BANNING AND REGISTERING CERTAIN BREEDS OF DOGS AND ANIMALS WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF HOT SPRINGS, ARKANSAS.

SECTION 2.

(a) Banned pit bull breeds of dogs are banned entirely and may not be owned or kept within the City. Banned breeds of pit bull dogs are any of the following:

(1) American Pit Bull Terrier;

(2) Staffordshire Bull Terrier, unless they meet the requirements of Subsection 3-1-5(b);

(3) American Staffordshire Terrier, unless they meet the requirements of Subsection 3-1-5(b);

(4) American Bull Dog;

(5) Any dog whose sire or dam is a dog of a breed which is defined as a banned breed of dog under this section;

(6) Any dog whose owner registers, defines, admits, or otherwise identifies the dog as being of a banned breed;

(7) Any dog conforming or substantially conforming to the breed of American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier, or American Bull Dog as defined by the United Kennel Club, American Dog Breeders Association, or American Kennel Club;

(8) Any dog which is of the breed commonly referred to as “pit bull” and commonly recognizable and identifiable as such.

CITY OF HOT SPRINGS AGENDA ITEM # 19

BOARD ACTION REQUEST O-09-43

DISCUSSION: Providing that certain dog breeds be banned from ownership within the incorporated limits of the City of Hot Springs. Also providing a registration requirement for dogs that are of “Banned Breed” status to comply with the ordinance for “Grandfathering” at the time of the passage of this ordinance. On November 17, 2009 the Animal Services Advisory Committee provided their findings via attached letter. Also find attached my report entitled “Breed Specific Considerations for Municipalities” that reviews three Arkansas Municipalities approach to controlling dangerous dogs and the fiscal impact of providing either type of ordinance approach.

Also attached is an excerpt from City of Hot Springs Ordinance that displays the manner that we currently handle “dangerous dog cases” and finally attached is a letter from the National Park Kennel Club and their recommendations for addressing this issue.

FISCAL IMPACT: A significant increase of enforcement duties will require additional staffing to ensure compliance with the ordinance, as well as supplies and veterinary services for the spay/neuter aspect of this ordinance. $100,000 annually for the first two years for two additional Animal Control Officers and equipment for a Breed Ban, and that same amount of funding in a perpetual manner for a updated Breed Regulation program. Fundamentally, we may not actually be at this juncture had the Animal Services Department been provided officer staffing levels that it has requested for the past several years and been capable of more pro-active neighborhood work and enforcement.

My recommendation in the report falls form my experience of funding for the Department, and the reality that funding has not been adequate even though we have justified that increased revenues the Department has collected that would offset any increased costs in staffing levels.

ALTERNATIVES: Do not adopt ordinance/ Amend Dangerous Dog ordinance

Queensland/Gold Coast, Australia: The pit bull is the usual suspect

Visit the link below to read a lengthy but interesting article on the effects of the breed ban in Australia, featuring two major problems: breed identification and expense to enforce (lawsuits).

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/features/the-pit-bull-is-the-usual-suspect/story-e6frg8h6-1225804507090

The pit bull is the usual suspect

Lucas County, OH: County to stop killing “pit bull” puppies

Identification of a “pit bull” is difficult enough; identification of a “pit bull” puppy is even more so. Dog warden Tom Skeldon apparently had no set criteria to identify “pit bulls,” as he could not produce this criteria when requested to do so by the Dog Warden Advisory Committee.

Previous alerts for Lucas County: http://stopbsl.com/?s=lucas+county

Lucas County orders end to puppy euthanasia

Dog warden’s TV remarks draw ire

By TOM TROY
BLADE POLITICS WRITER
Article published November 25, 2009

The Lucas County commissioners voted yesterday to prohibit Lucas County Dog Warden Tom Skeldon from killing puppies at least through 3 months of age, including, for the first time in years, “pit bull” puppies.

[...] The advisory committee specifically included “pit bulls” in the moratorium for two reasons – because no 3-month-old puppy of any breed would be a threat to people and because it is too difficult to determine that such a young dog is a “pit bull.”[...]

Full article retrieved 11/26/09 from http://toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20091125/NEWS16/911250344/-1/NEWS04

Tasmania, Australia: Tougher Controls on Dangerous Dogs (BSL passed)

The following dogs are now considered “restricted breeds” in Tasmania. There are special requirements for owners of these types of dogs:

(a) dogo Argentino;
(b) fila Brasileiro;
(c) Japanese tosa;
(d) American pit bull terrier or pit bull terrier;
(e) Perro de Presa Canario or Presa Canario;
(f) any other breed, kind or description of dog whose importation into Australia is prohibited by or under the Customs Act 1901 of the Commonwealth.

Read the entire Dog Control Amendment Act 2009 here: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/tas/bill/dcab27o2009243/

http://www.media.tas.gov.au/release.php?id=28515

Tougher Controls on Dangerous Dogs

[...] Changes to the Act include:

• Stronger control measures on dangerous dogs, including child-proof enclosures of a minimum standard.
• Stronger provisions for councils to seize and detain dogs.
• A new noise abatement notice process to tackle problem barking dogs.
• A new classification of restricted breed dog with stronger control requirements.
• Mandatory de-sexing of restricted breed dogs and dangerous dogs.
• Restrictions on selling and exchanging dangerous and restricted breed dogs.
• Compulsory micro-chipping of all dogs.[...]

Des Moines, IA: D.M. tables plan to change vicious dog rules (additional BSL dropped)

Des Moines already has BSL, and because it’s not working very well, the city council considered making the breed-specific ordinance even more strict. These plans have now been tabled (put on hold indefinitely).

Previous alerts for Des Moines: http://stopbsl.com/?s=des+moines

D.M. tables plan to change vicious dog rules

By JASON PULLIAM • jpulliam@dmreg.com • November 24, 2009

A proposal to increase fees to license so-called vicious dogs has been tabled by the Des Moines City Council.

Council members called for more public input and time to study whether the fees and other proposed changes to the city’s vicious dog ordinance would have worthwhile results.[...]

Full article retrieved 11/25/09 from http://www.desmoinesregister.com/article/20091124/NEWS/911240357/1001/NEWS/D.M.-tables-plan-to-change-vicious-dog-rules

East China Twnshp and St. Clair County, MI: Whispers of BSL

A resident of East China Township, MI, has requested that the Board of Trustees consider implementing BSL similar to that of Mt. Clemens. The same resident is pushing St. Clair County to pass similar legislation.

East China, MI

Next East China Township board meeting: December 7 and December 21, 7:30 PM
Township Hall, 5111 River Road, East China, Mi., 48054
(810) 765-8879

Contact info per http://www.eastchinatownship.org/feedbk.html:
Township Supervisor John A. Randolph, jack@eastchinatownship.org
Township Clerk Gary Arnold, gary@eastchinatownship.org
Township Treasurer Donald K. Beaudua, cindon1978@comcast.net
Township Trustee Richard Bober, vajar@sbcglobal.net
Township Trustee Larry J. Simons, simonslj@hotmail.com
Township Trustee Angelo Patsalis, vajar@sbcglobal.net
Township Trustee Donald Horn (no email available)

St. Clair County, MI

Next Board of Commissioners Meeting: December 2, 6:00 PM
St. Clair County Administration Building, 2nd Floor – Board Room, 200 Grand River, Port Huron, MI 48060

Commissioners Office
200 Grand River, Suite 203, Port Huron, MI 48060
Phone: 810-989-6900
Fax: 810-985-3463

District 1 Steven L. Simasko
ssimasko@stclaircounty.org

District 2 Dennis M. Kearns
dkearns@stclaircounty.org

District 3 Howard Heidemann
hheidemann@stclaircounty.org

District 4 Patrick W. Quain
pquain@stclaircounty.org

District 5 Jeff Bohm
jbohm@stclaircounty.org

District 6 Wallace R. Evans
wevans@stclaircounty.org

District 7 Pamela Wall
pwall@stclaircounty.org

Link to the opinion article that prompted this alert: http://www.thetimesherald.com/article/20091124/OPINION03/911240325/-1/NEWSFRONT2/County-must-move-to-contain-pit-bull-threat

Pender County, NC: Neighbors push for stronger animal control in Pender County

This is a situation to keep an eye on. Effective non-breed-specific ordinances should be suggested to county commissioners.

Next County Commission meeting: December 14, 7:00 PM
BOCC Meeting Room, Pender County Admin. Building, 805 S. Walker St. Burgaw, NC 28425

Commissioners’ Contact Info:

Jimmy Tate – Chairman (5th District)
university@ec.rr.com
910-285-5444

George Brown – Vice Chairman (3rd District)
browng@pender-county.com
910-675-8653

David Williams, Jr. – Commissioner (1st District)
williamsd2@pender-county.com
Phone: 910-270-7757
Fax: 910-270-7757

Norwood Blanchard – Commissioner (2nd District)
blanchardn@pender-county.com
910-259-2003

F.D. Rivenbark – Commissioner (4th District)
rivenbarkf@pender-county.com
Phone: 910-259-2717
Fax: 910-259-7480

Neighbors push for stronger animal control in Pender County

By K.J. Williams
Citydesk@StarNewsOnline.Com
Published: Monday, November 23, 2009 at 11:44 a.m.
Last Modified: Monday, November 23, 2009 at 11:44 a.m.

Several Pender County residents are taking a grassroots approach to combating dog attacks by asking for stronger animal control ordinances.

[...] They plan to attend the Pender County Commissioners meeting at noon on Dec. 14 to ask commissioners to outline specific procedures on dealing with dangerous dogs.[...]

Full article retrieved 11/24/09 from http://www.starnewsonline.com/article/20091123/ARTICLES/911239988/1004?tc=autorefresh

Erie, PA: Incidents renew calls for regulation of pit bulls, other vicious dogs

Article writer Kara Murphy needs education about how to interpret dog bite statistics and how to identify credible scientific sources (see “Journalist Resources: Scientific Studies” to understand why Animal People/Merritt Clifton’s so-called “study” is not legitimate scientific research): kara.murphy@timesnews.com

City shelter manager Kris Watkins needs education about no-kill initiatives, how to decrease the kill rate, and how to save more “pit bulls” (first step: stop talking about “pit bulls” in a way that feeds the vicious stereotype): staff@theannashelter.com or 814-451-0230.

Erie can’t pass BSL due to state law, but City Councilmembers need information about effective non-breed-specific dangerous dog laws, preferably from locals who understand why the current dog laws are failing.

Send correspondence to the entire City Council by sending to the city clerk:

City Clerk Jim Klemm
Email: jeklemm@erie.pa.us
Phone: (814) 870-1291
Fax: (814) 870-1296

Dept. City Clerk Gloria Criscione
Email: gloriac@erie.pa.us
Phone: (814) 870-1292
Fax: (814) 870-1296

Incidents renew calls for regulation of pit bulls, other vicious dogs

By KARA MURPHY
kara.murphy@timesnews.com
Published: November 23. 2009 1:15AM

[...] The recent attacks have raised questions of whether regulations on pit bull owners should be tightened, an idea that Erie police last raised in 2007 after a series of attacks involving the breed, including two incidents in which Erie police officers shot and killed attacking pit bulls.

But City Councilman Jim Thompson said state law prohibits local governing bodies from putting in place breed-specific laws. He pursued the idea of tightening regulations against pit bull owners several years ago.[...]

Full article retrieved 11/24/09 from http://www.goerie.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20091123/NEWS02/311239975

Sturgis, MI: Dog ordinances to be reviewed (whispers of BSL)

Nothing official has been proposed. However, Commissioners are looking at ordinances from surrounding cities—including the city of Elkhart’s proposed BSL.

Next City Commission meeting: Dec. 9, 9:30 PM, Wiesloch Raum – City Hall

Contact info for City Commissioners

Mayor John Carmichael
jcarmichael@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Vice Mayor Barbara Fisher
bfisher@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner David Smith
dsmith@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Karl Littman
klittman@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Ina Taulbee
itaulbee@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Karen Stephens
kstephens@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Ken Malone
kmalone@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Suzy Saddler
ssaddler@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Commissioner Mike Gay
mgay@ci.sturgis.mi.us

Crossposted from BSL Updates:

Post office, commission urge review of ordinances

By Terry Katz katz@sturgisjournal.com
Sturgis Journal
Tue Nov 24, 2009, 04:18 AM EST

[...] City commissioners agreed unan­imously to start looking at dog or­dinances with teeth.

[...] Commissioners also directed City Manager Mike Hughes to check with the City of Elkhart about types of enforcement, including a vicious breed ordinance that’s been under discussion.[...]

Full article retrieved 11/24/10 from http://www.sturgisjournal.com/news/x2072218547/Post-office-commission-urge-review-of-ordinances

Genesee County, MI: Pit bull debate continues as communities deal with dangerous dogs

Sadly, the people “speaking out in defense of pit bulls” did nothing to lessen the pit bull and pit bull owner stereotype; the residents were a group of breeders, and their dogs were featured on the news wearing spiked collars, being restrained on thick logging chains. A comment from below the news story reads: “I hear all these people tell how safe their pit bulls are, and then see that one’s using a heavy chain for a leash! Give me a break!!”

Previous alert for Genesee County: http://stopbsl.com/2009/11/09/2488/

Although the Flint City Council president does not expect a pit bull ban to be proposed, that doesn’t mean some other type of BSL isn’t a possibility.

Next city council meetings: November 23 and December 14

Contact info for Flint City Council:

City Council Office, Rm 310 City Hall, Flint, MI  48502
810-766-7418
Fax: (810) 766-7032

Delrico J. Loyd – 1st Ward
President
810-766-7418 ext. 3160
dloyd@cityofflint.com

Jackie Foster Poplar – 2nd Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3162 

Bryant W. Nolden – 3rd Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3159

Joshua M. Freeman – 4th Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3161

Bernard Lawler – 5th Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3164

Sheldon Neeley- 6th Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3165
sneeley@cityofflint.com 

Dale K. Weighill – 7th Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3163

Michael J. Sarginson – 8th Ward
810-766-7418 ext. 3167

Scott Kincaid – 9th Ward
810-766-7418

Pit bull debate continues as communities deal with dangerous dogs

Sunday, November 22, 2009 at 7:09 p.m.

[...] Flint City Council President Delrico Loyd says there has been casual talk among city leaders about what to do about dangerous dogs, but he doesn’t expect a ban on any specific breeds.

For the full story, click on the video icon above.

Full article retrieved 11/23/09 from http://www.uppermichiganssource.com/news/story.aspx?id=380765