Fremont, OH update: Dog law discussion continues at council (BSL under consideration)

Previous alerts for Fremont: http://stopbsl.com/?s=fremont%2C+oh

Remember: Ohio state law already considers pit bulls to be “vicious” dogs, with special regulations for owners.

http://www.thenews-messenger.com/article/20091120/NEWS01/911200310

Dog law discussion continues at council

BY LESLIE BIXLER • Staff writer • November 20, 2009

FREMONT — No decision was made Thursday regarding pit bulls and other dog breeds in the city, but the consensus from residents and city officials is that owners should be responsible for their dogs.

Several residents voiced their opinions and talked about their experiences with pit bulls and other breeds during the laws, rules and ordinance committee meeting before City Council met. This was the third city discussion of the topic.

Each person had five minutes to speak.

Judy McKinney talked about an attack she witnessed in her neighborhood, when a pit bull ran from its house and attacked a small dog that a family was taking for a walk.

“I hear there are good and bad dogs, and I don’t want anyone to lose a good pet …,” she said. “There’s got to be some way to make owners responsible.”

Scott Williams said his niece was involved in the incident McKinney witnessed.

“We really need to protect the public,” he said. “We need a way to identify dogs that will attack.”

Williams said he has had two relatives attacked by dogs. One case involved a pit bull, and the other involved a rottweiler. He, too, agreed owners need to be responsible.

Penny Forsythe, a local business owner, was with her daughter Nichole and son-in-law Jason Wolf at the meeting. She said she feels her grandchildren are safe around pit bulls, and that the dogs are not vicious.

Jason Wolf said, “You have to train that dog and be stern with it. If you want to have the dog of your choice, you should … but train it and love it every day, just like your kids.”

Council President Duane Simmons said he has a problem identifying vicious dogs. He said that when he was a meter reader, he was bitten by a Labrador retriever that didn’t seem aggressive.

“The people that don’t care about their dogs are the ones we have to make the law tough enough for so they understand,” Simmons said.

Councilwoman Karen Wagner and councilman Richard Root said they’re not in favor of a ban for any dog.

“We just need to do something about the vicious dogs,” Root said.

Mayor Terry Overmyer said he was shocked at seeing some of the pictures after an attack, and he said the city needs to go after people who are not responsible owners.

Councilman James Melle said council would take everything under advisement before drafting legislation.

[Irrelevant text elided.]

Fremont, OH update: Council hears about other dog laws

BSL is still under consideration in Fremont. A third public meeting will take place at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 19.

Previous alerts on Fremont, OH: http://stopbsl.com/?s=fremont%2C+oh

Fremont Law Director Bob Hart, who is pushing for the ban: 419-334-2908

City Councilmembers’ Contact Info:
Mike Koebel, 419-334-4231 home, 419-332-5300 work
Jim Melle, jmelle@fremontohio.org
Larry Jackson, ljackson@fremontohio.org
O. Duane Simmons, odsimmons@fremontohio.org
Rick Root, rroot@fremontohio.org
Jim Weaver, jweaver@fremontohio.org
Karen Wagner, pwags43@yahoo.com
Don Nalley, nalley1stward@aol.com

http://www.thenews-messenger.com/article/20091106/NEWS01/911060305

Council hears about other dog laws

BY LESLIE BIXLER • Staff writer • November 6, 2009

FREMONT — City hall was once again packed Thursday night as residents came to hear more about what other states and municipalities are doing about vicious dogs. City officials want to gather information to decide whether to enact a dog policy here.

Ledy VanKavage, an attorney with the Best Friends Animal Society out of Illinois, spoke to council Thursday about different laws.

At the Oct. 15 public meeting at city hall, Fremont police Chief Tim Wiersma, Ohio Coalition of Dog Advocates’ Jean Keating and Sandusky County’s deputy dog warden Gina Halbisen debated pit bulls.

“Any dog can bite and we need to focus on the individuals (who own them),” VanKavage said in her presentation.

In 2006, 84 percent of fatal dog attacks involved reckless owners, according to a statistic in her presentation.

No one knows how many German shepherds, pit bulls or other types of dogs there are in communities, and people go through cycles deciding which dogs are dangerous, she said. She said she once had a German shepherd, and as she was walking the dog, someone told her to be careful because it could turn on her.

VanKavage discussed canine profiling laws and how the U.K. banned pit bulls in 1991. However, there has not been a published U.S. study on the laws. She also said the breed ban in Denver is not working. According to her presentation, breed-specific legislation is not as effective as more strict dangerous-dog laws, which hold owners responsible.

Texas prohibits dogs being tied up between certain hours of the day, within 500 feet of a school and during certain temperatures because dogs that are chained can be more aggressive.

She also stressed the importance of dogs being spayed or neutered and microchipped, as some states require.

Lucas County has more than 800 dog bites a year, which is a lot for a county that size, she said. There, people can have only one pit bull, but the bites have increased, she said.

VanKavage said identification is also a problem because people tend to misidentify a dog as a pit bull when it might be a mixed breed.

City Law Director Bob Hart said, “I want to do what is best for Fremont. I’m starting to buy this owner’s responsibility. But I’m still troubled. … I can’t deny what I’ve seen when someone was attacked by a pit bull.”

Councilman Mike Koebel asked, “Is it true that pit bulls jaws lock?”

VanKavage said that their jaws do not lock when they bite, they are just muscular.

A third public meeting will take place at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 19.

Fremont, OH: Fremont council hears opinions on pit bulls

Previous stories on Fremont, OH: http://stopbsl.com/?s=Fremont%2C+OH

http://www.thenews-messenger.com/article/20091016/NEWS01/910160307

Fremont council hears opinions on pit bulls

Police chief, dog advocates weigh in

BY LESLIE BIXLER • Staff writer • October 16, 2009

FREMONT — City hall was packed Thursday night to hear Fremont police Chief Tim Wiersma, Ohio Coalition of Dog Advocates’ Jean Keating and Sandusky County’s deputy dog warden Gina Halbisen debate pit bulls.

Councilman James Melle, who is chairman of the laws, rules and ordinance committee, said before the meeting that the purpose was to gather information before considering any legislation.

“Let’s educate ourselves,” City Law Director Bob Hart said. “We’re here to listen to all points of view.”

Wiersma presented information on dog-related calls since 2005, which was requested on behalf of Mayor Terry Overmyer and council. He said there have been five pit bull attacks in each year. But there has also been other dog attacks with numerous other breeds, which have been more consistent and were in the range between 15 and 18 per year.

Councilman James Weaver asked if the pit bull attacks were to humans or other dogs, and Wiersma said both.

However, not all dog-related calls, which were fewer than 200 a year, were just bites or attacks, but also included dogs running loose and other minor incidents.

“We want safe communities and safety for our children. But we need to balance safety and the rights of a person to own what they want to own,” Keating said.

She said there have been roughly 30 human deaths a year by dogs. She went on to say that 84 people die a year from forklift injuries.

She stressed the importance of dog safety for children.

“We have had people killed in this country from Yorkshire Terriers,” she said.

Keating also said part of the problem is pit bulls get a bad reputation because of the media and people who can’t identify breeds.

“Every dog with a block (shaped) head and broad shoulders isn’t a pit bull,” she said.

She believes the heart of the problem is irresponsible owners.

Halbisen said in her 15 years of experience, she has seen a lot of irresponsible owners, and there have been pit bull attacks in the last few months.

“My job is to protect people of Sandusky County and the people of Fremont from vicious dogs,” she said. “Pit bull attacks are horrendous and nobody should have to go through that.”

She said she goes into the schools about six times a year to talk about dog safety and dog bites.

At another meeting at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 5, Ledy VanKavage, of the Best Friends Animal Society out of Illinois, will speak about pit bulls.

[Irrelevant text elided]

Fremont, OH reminder: City council to discuss possible “pit bull” ban, October 15

Fremont City Council will meet October 15, 6:30 p.m., at city hall to discuss “what to do about pit bulls in the city.”

Previous alert: http://stopbsl.com/2009/09/23/fremont-oh-pit-bull-ban-suggested/

Fremont Law Director Bob Hart, who is pushing for the ban: 419-334-2908

City Councilmembers’ Contact Info:
Mike Koebel, 419-334-4231 home, 419-332-5300 work
Jim Melle, jmelle@fremontohio.org
Larry Jackson, ljackson@fremontohio.org
O. Duane Simmons, odsimmons@fremontohio.org
Rick Root, rroot@fremontohio.org
Jim Weaver, jweaver@fremontohio.org
Karen Wagner, pwags43@yahoo.com
Don Nalley, nalley1stward@aol.com

The following statement from the article is not correct: “At an August council meeting, City Law Director Bob Hart said the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of regulating pit bulls.” I do not know whether it was the journalist’s error or the law director’s error, but the U.S. Supreme Court has never ruled in favor of regulating pit bulls. The U.S. Supreme Court has never even heard such a case. The reference may possibly be to an Ohio Supreme Court ruling.

http://www.thenews-messenger.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20091012/NEWS01/910120306

Fremont group opposes breed-specific laws

BY LESLIE BIXLER • Staff writer • October 12, 2009

FREMONT — A group of citizens gathered Sunday afternoon to learn more about why breed-specific laws for dogs don’t work.

Locals gathered at 521 White Road to voice their concerns about the possibility of pit bulls being regulated by the city.

Jean Keating, of Ohio Coalition of Dog Advocates, Inc., out of Avon Lake said, “We basically try to promote responsible dog ownership in the state, and we’re working with legislators on removing the term ‘pit bull’ from Ohio’s definition of a vicious dog.” According to the coalition, the laws don’t work because they do nothing to address the proven factors that contribute to a dog’s likelihood of displaying dangerous behavior such as owner responsibility, abuse and neglect, being inhumanely chained, not being spayed or neutered and dogs roaming at large.

However, Barbara McGrady, of Citizens Opposing Breed Specific Legislation, told those at the meeting that this is what people need to think about, “Banning certain breeds does not address the serious nature of the problem surrounding dog attacks; people who abuse animals and those who are irresponsible. Both of these activities place the community as a whole at risk.”

Brent Soper, of Fremont, brought in his pit bull, Roxy, who he has had for nine years.

“(She’s) the best dog I’ve ever owned, she’s never left my yard in nine years,” he said. When he brought Roxy in, she wagged her tail and made her way to each person as they petted her. The rest of the time she laid calmly by Soper’s side. He feels the breed isn’t at fault, and that’s the owners are at fault for a dog’s behavior.

Nichole and Jason Wolf, of Fremont, also brought in their two pit bulls, which also were friendly to those at the meeting.

While Nichole agrees that there are good and bad dogs in every breed, she says if pit bulls are regulated in some way, “it will only hurt the responsible (dog) owners.”

But Jane Pollak, of Fremont, feels differently about the breed. Pollak, who was not at the meeting was contacted by telephone Sunday afternoon. She, too agrees that owners are responsible for how a dog behaves.

Last May, two pit bulls had gotten loose from a nearby home and made their way into her garage, where her 15-year-old cocker-mix, Abby, was attacked by the dogs. Abby died four days later from the injuries. Pollak said her main garage door had been closed, but she also has two side doors, and one of them was left open, which is how the two dogs came in.

“I do feel sorry for the dogs because they were put down, because it’s not their fault, it’s the owners,” Pollak said. “I would never trust a pit bull, even though I know they can be nice family dogs.”

There is a laws, rules and ordinance meeting of the Fremont City Council at 6:30 p.m. Thursday at city hall to discuss the issue regarding what to do about pit bulls in the city. There will be four guest speakers. At an August council meeting, City Law Director Bob Hart said the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of regulating pit bulls. Hart had also encouraged council members to talk to residents about the issue.

Judy and Bill McKinney, of Fremont, witnessed an attack by a pit bull last month from their home. The McKinneys were also contact by telephone Sunday afternoon.

Judy said she was sitting in her home and had heard a woman screaming “Stop!” “Stop!” When she looked outside, a neighbor’s pit bull was attacking a small dog that a family was taking for a walk on a leash.

“I’d never seen an attack before and I never want to see one again,” Judy McKinney said, noting she fears for a person or another dog being attacked.

“No one should have to worry when walking their dogs on a leash,” she said, noting the owner of the pit bull had gotten rid of the dog after the attack.

Pollak said she appreciates what Hart has asked council to consider.

“I don’t want to make dog owners mad, but something needs to be done,” she said.

At the meeting, Keating said she is in the process of having the Sandusky County Dog Warden’s office gather dog bite records for review.

“We’re the only state that has breed specific legislation state-wide,” she said.

Fremont, OH: Pit bull ban suggested

Nothing official has been proposed. However, city councilmembers are discussing the possibility of a ban on “pit bulls” in Fremont. Remember: the state of Ohio already considers all “pit bulls” to be legally classified as “vicious dogs.”

There will be a town meeting on the issue at City Hall on October 15 at 6:30 PM.

Fremont Law Director Bob Hart, who is pushing for the ban: 419-334-2908

City Councilmembers’ Contact Info:
Mike Koebel, 419-334-4231 home, 419-332-5300 work
Jim Melle, jmelle@fremontohio.org
Larry Jackson, ljackson@fremontohio.org
O. Duane Simmons, odsimmons@fremontohio.org
Rick Root, rroot@fremontohio.org
Jim Weaver, jweaver@fremontohio.org
Karen Wagner, pwags43@yahoo.com
Don Nalley, nalley1stward@aol.com

A transcript of the city council meeting can be found here: http://mypetrescueblog.blogspot.com/2009/09/town-hall-meeting-on-pit-bull-ban-in.html

Ohio article: Humane Society’s power grows (mention of BSL)

Humane Society’s power grows

Animal welfare gaining attention

News Messenger and
Gannett News Service reports
December 6, 2008

[This is a lengthy article; the most relevant text is retained. Please follow the article link for the full text.]

Barb McGrady, president and founder of the Society for the Protection of Animals in Fremont, wants the gains in Washington to bring more attention to major issues in Ohio, especially a law being considered in the Ohio House to ban pit bulls from the state and the growing number of backyard dog breeders.

The pit bull law, proposed by State Rep. Tyrone Yates, D-Cincinnati, would give owners 90 days to move their pit bulls out of Ohio, or the dogs will be confiscated and euthanized. The society, which is a shelter for abandoned animals, believes the proposed law unfairly targets a breed of dogs that is incorrectly branded as viscous.

During the past 10 years, the society has rescued hundreds of dogs, and the pit bull is the only breed it has helped that has not shown aggression toward people, she said. McGrady said she uses a female pit bull in outreach education programs because it is so gentle and people-friendly.

“She is the only dog that we trust 110 percent around children,” McGrady wrote in a letter to Yates. “Her temperament is solid as steel, and she is one of the most even tempered dogs I have ever met.”

Like McGrady, Megan Feicht, shelter manager for the Ottawa County Humane Society in Port Clinton, is concerned about the pit bull law and stereotypes regarding the breed. The shelter has five pit bulls and has more difficulty finding them homes than any other breed of dog, she said.